What someone would buy if your business came apart

Most conversations about AI and the future of a business ask whether the business survives. A more useful question is what a buyer would pick out of it if it didn't.

Gareth Rydon5 min read

Thanks for coming back for issue ten. Last issue was about where AI-built work lives once it exists. This one starts with a law firm that came apart, and with who turned up to bid for the pieces.

Weil Gotshal is a New York firm with about 1,200 lawyers, and it is heading for dissolution. I wrote to a lot of my contacts about it this week. I want to say what the coverage does and doesn’t say first, because the AI part of the story is smaller than it looks.

None of what I read blames AI for what happened to Weil. Its leading partners left. Michael Aiello, a rainmaker, went to Cravath with a team of partners, a co-managing partner was reported to be in talks with Simpson Thacher, and merger talks with Willkie Farr & Gallagher broke down (Semafor). Vetta, one of the bidders, says Weil was not failing financially and that the firm came apart after leading partners left (Artificial Lawyer).

Then three AI-native firms bid for pieces of it. Crosby put in a letter of intent on 29 October for Weil’s trademark, brand and internal data, and is trying to hire some of the lawyers (Runtime Wire). Vetta wants the precedents, playbooks and knowledge-management infrastructure, and the lawyers. Scissero has put in an expression of interest in the technology, intellectual property and data, and says it is already talking to several Weil lawyers (Artificial Lawyer). No one I read about bid for the firm as it stood. They bid for pieces of what was inside it.

The pattern: the wrapper and the asset


A business is two things at once, and for most of its life nobody needs to tell them apart. The wrapper is the structure that holds the value together and carries it to the customer: the brand, the partnership model, the interface, the process. The asset is whatever the customer would still pay for if the wrapper disappeared.

The two stay stuck together because the only way to reach a customer used to be through the wrapper, and building a rival wrapper took years and a lot of money. AI has made a rival wrapper much cheaper to build. A firm can now be set up with AI doing the volume work and lawyers doing the judgement. When a wrapper is cheap to copy, it is less likely to be the reason anyone wants to buy the business.

Inside the business, it can look as though nothing is happening. I read the wrapper as the part that shows up in the budget, the org chart and the board paper, so it keeps getting the attention. The assets are harder to see until someone outside puts a price on them. This is my reading of public reporting. I haven’t watched it happen inside a client, so the evidence is thinner than in most issues.

The wreckage test


The test I would use has two questions. If the business came apart, what would a buyer pay for? That sorts the wrapper from the asset. And could they actually take it? The second question is the harder one.

For Weil, the partnership structure and the way the firm was led sit on the wrapper side. The lawyers, precedents, playbooks, technology and data sit on the asset side, along with the client trust that comes with them.

Weil’s bidders answered the second question in public. Vetta says a precedent may be usable only if it holds no client information or details of the past deal, and that anyone taking IP has to confirm they are allowed to. Scissero says it wants lawful use of Weil’s accumulated knowledge and data, not unrestricted access to confidential client information, and that each category needs its own assessment, safeguards and client consents. The lawyers decide for themselves whether to join. One report notes that Weil’s value depends on partners and client trust, which can leave before a sale closes.

So the assets a buyer wants most are the ones the firm controls least. The people can walk, the client trust sits with the clients, and a precedent can carry someone else’s confidential work.

Option one: protect the wrapper


The usual response is to treat the business as the thing to protect. For Weil, that meant a partnership that kept its best people in place. According to Semafor, current and former lawyers blamed the executive partner for not convincing senior partners that Weil had a vision for a future in which AI and very high pay packages reshape the value of top-end legal advice. A partner who isn’t convinced can leave, and the leading ones did.

I read this as the wrapper doing its job until it stopped holding the people. Once enough of them had gone, the firm came apart, which matches Vetta’s account.

Option two: decide what the asset is first


The bidders took the other route, from the outside. Vetta describes its own model as one where a lawyer’s value lies in judgement and client relationships, while AI does much of the volume work. Whatever you think of that claim, it is a decision about what the asset is, made before the wreckage.

Crosby’s bid for the brand shows the sort is not always wrapper bad, asset good. A name that still carries trust can be worth buying. One report frames the bid as a test of whether an AI-native firm can use a legacy firm’s brand, templates and lawyers as an advantage that software vendors cannot copy.

Each bidder also has something to sell, and each gains from telling this story. I would read their descriptions of Weil as claims.

Where this has got to


This is not settled and I would rather say so. The terms of the bids have not been disclosed, and I could not find a decision on any of them. Sources disagree on whether Weil was failing financially: Vetta says it wasn’t, and other coverage describes it as failing. I also can’t tell you whether any bidder ends up with the lawyers, which decides whether the rest is worth much.

What changed how I read the news was the list of what the bidders chose to pick up.

What it costs


The cost of not asking shows up late. A business that has never sorted its wrapper from its assets finds out what its assets are when someone else prices them: in a bid, in merger talks, or in a resignation letter. A business that has done the sort knows which things it has to keep hold of and which it can let a better wrapper replace.

Tell us the job that makes you sigh.

You’ll leave the call knowing whether it’s worth doing, and what we’d do first.

Book a call